The Link Between Employee Motivation and Your Compensation Philosophy
Becky Byrd
Dec 06, 2016
Do your employees understand your company’s compensation philosophy? That was a question posed to human resource managers in a recent WorldatWork survey, Compensation Programs and Practices. According to the survey, almost one in five employers believe that most of their employees have a basic understanding of how their pay is determined. However, nearly half of employers in the survey estimate that most of their workforce has little or no understanding.
Those results might not be surprising in light of another survey result: Only 62% of employers have a written compensation philosophy document to share with employees. Nearly one-third said they have an unwritten philosophy, and 7% confessed they don’t have a compensation philosophy at all.
Common Pay Target
In practice, the majority of employers simply aim to set pay at the median for a given job category in their labor market. But just paying a median wage, if it can be called a compensation philosophy, isn’t one that will excite most employees if it’s explained to them as such.
Still, nearly the same percentage use some form of variable pay, typically a bonus, to reward exemplary performance. Presumably this reflects a compensation philosophy that not all employees in the same job category should be paid the same every year.
Though most employers tell employees (or at least imply) that they will be rewarded if they achieve certain goals, nearly a third say they plan to give bonuses even to those who didn’t achieve performance expectations. While such employees might appreciate the bonus, their employer loses all credibility in the process.
CEO Pay Multiples
The amount of pressure on publicly held companies to be clear about their compensation philosophy is about to explode, and it could spill over to some smaller companies. That’s because under new Securities and Exchange Commission rules, public companies beginning in 2017 will be required to report the ratio of their CEOs’ pay to that of median employee pay.
That multiple has been estimated at 300, and executive pay has risen at a much faster rate than typical employees for many years. When the figures start being reported, sensitivity to how compensation levels are determined will grow.
Here are some compensation philosophy questions to consider, then resolve and communicate to employees:
- Are small annual raises a trap? Many employers have dropped the practice of spreading around modest (for example, 2% or 3%) raises broadly, because it limits funds available to give substantial pay raises to top performers. Also, the value of a job doesn’t move in lockstep with inflation (even when inflation is low, as it has been in recent years).
- Are you using the right benchmarks? While salary surveys can tell you average pay levels for particular jobs in your labor market, they can be misleading. That’s because in your own organization, an employee whose job pays, for instance, $40,000 on average in your community, might be worth a lot more — or less — to you because of factors unique to your organization. An employee who understands his or her value to you, particularly when it’s high, probably won’t be content with pay that simply matches a market average.
- What employee behaviors are you rewarding? It’s important to establish a clear link between the activities you’re rewarding and your strategic goals. For example, if your goal is to raise employee skill levels to equip them to assume greater responsibility, are they rewarded for acquiring those skills, or simply performing well at their existing jobs?
- Is your incentive system overly complicated? It may be tempting to devise a bonus system that touches on every possible metric of employee performance. But employees aren’t finely tuned machines that can calibrate their efforts precisely in response to multiple incentives. If they feel as though they’re being pulled in too many directions, or don’t really understand the formula, the bonus will lose potency.
Why Communication Matters
After you’ve reviewed and perhaps revised your compensation philosophy, communicating it to employees is crucial. They consider the manner in which you pay them as the acid test of what you want from them. Intangibles matter too, of course, like the quality and tone of the work environment. If pay practices are a mystery, you lose on two counts: Employees don’t like being kept in the dark, and they won’t know which behaviors will bring tangible rewards.
Simply describing your compensation philosophy in an employee handbook won’t get the job done. While that’s a necessary starting point, discussing it directly with employees and answering their questions, generally in the context of a performance review, makes it more comprehensible.
Finally, be sure employees understand all of the elements of their compensation, and the philosophy behind it. If their paychecks represent, for example, only 70% of their total compensation when the value of benefits is added in, it’s important for them to understand that. It will also give them something to think about if they’re tempted to seek a job with another employer because they’ve heard the wages are good, without knowing the whole story.
If you would like to review your compensation strategy and how to stimulate business growth while benefiting everyone involved with your business, call us at 513-858-6040. Let us help you enhance the value of your business.
Copyright@2016
About The Author
As an expert in QBO, tax planning, and Federal, State and Local Tax, Becky provides business owners with…
Tags
Sign Up for Email Updates
Related Articles
Do You Know How SECURE 2.0 Will Affect Your Manufacturing Company?
- 03-16-23
- Kirsch CPA Group
Top 3 Federal Tax Law Changes that Could Affect Your Business Return
- 03-02-23
- Kirsch CPA Group
What Are the Most Common Form 990 Mistakes Not-for-Profits Make?
- 02-16-23
- Kirsch CPA Group
8 Ways to Insulate Your Construction Company Against Rising Costs
- 02-10-23
- Kirsch CPA Group
Tax Treatment of Debt Forgiveness: Watch Out for Tax Bills Delivered COD
- 01-18-23
- Kirsch CPA Group
Manufacturers: Be Aware of These 3 Business Tax Provisions Currently in Limbo
- 01-18-23
- Kirsch CPA Group
The Tax Deductible Mileage Rate for Business Driving Increases for 2023
- 01-04-23
- Kirsch CPA Group
Succession Planning Considerations for Construction Business Owners
- 12-14-22
- Kirsch CPA Group
Prevent Fraud at Your Construction Company With a Holistic Approach
- 11-30-22
- Kirsch CPA Group
Manufacturers Must Act Now to Maximize Depreciation-Related Tax Breaks for 2022
- 11-09-22
- Kirsch CPA Group
It’s Time for Businesses to Rethink Their Working Capital Practices
- 11-09-22
- Kirsch CPA Group
Social Security Wage Base and Earnings Test Amounts Increase in 2023
- 10-27-22
- Kirsch CPA Group
New Law Enhances Payroll Tax Break for Small Manufacturers’ Research Expenses
- 10-13-22
- Kirsch CPA Group
How Buy-Sell Agreements Factor into Business Owners’ Estate Plans
- 09-14-22
- Kirsch CPA Group
SALT Cap Workaround Law Could Save Ohio Business Owners Over $100 Million
- 08-31-22
- Kirsch CPA Group
How Manufacturing Companies Can Benefit from the Section 179 Expensing Deduction
- 08-04-22
- Kirsch CPA Group
Could the Work Opportunity Tax Credit Help Your Construction Company?
- 06-23-22
- Kirsch CPA Group
Good News: IRS Boosts Standard Mileage Rates for Second Half of 2022
- 06-23-22
- Kirsch CPA Group
Education Benefits Can Help You Recruit and Retain Smart Employees
- 05-26-22
- Kirsch CPA Group
Ensure Your Construction Accounting System Has the Right Features
- 05-12-22
- Kirsch CPA Group
John Kirsch Named to Greater Butler and Warren Counties Business Hall of Fame
- 03-25-22
- Diane Glover
Manufacturers Need to Act Soon to Take Advantage of 100% First-year Bonus Depreciation
- 03-17-22
- Kirsch CPA Group
Commission Fraud: Salespeople Getting Paid More Than They’ve Earned
- 02-04-22
- Kirsch CPA Group
Consider a New Approach to Meeting Your Business Real Estate Need
- 09-17-21
- Kirsch CPA Group
Beware: Teleworking Arrangements May Cause State Tax Withholding Issues
- 08-18-21
- Kirsch CPA Group
5 Common Construction Accounting Risks — and How to Address Them
- 07-07-21
- Kirsch CPA Group
Supreme Court Finds No Standing to Challenge a Provision of the ACA
- 06-24-21
- Kirsch CPA Group
Labor Shortage: Unlock Solutions by Evaluating Your Employment Value Proposition
- 06-09-21
- Kirsch CPA Group
Material Participation Standard is the Key to Unlocking LLC Tax Losses
- 05-27-21
- Kirsch CPA Group
Know Your Legal Obligations Under the Americans with Disabilities Act
- 05-13-21
- Kirsch CPA Group
PPP Loan Not Forgiven? There’s a Safe Harbor for Deducting Expenses
- 12-03-20
- Kirsch CPA Group
What You Need to Know About the Deferral of Payroll Tax Obligations
- 09-15-20
- Kirsch CPA Group
PPP Loan Forgiveness – Significant Borrower Friendly Changes on the Horizon
- 06-04-20
- John Kirsch
Tax Filing Deadline Remains April 15 – Payment Due Extended to July 15
- 03-19-20
- John Kirsch
Prepare to Receive a Social Security Administration No-Match Letter
- 10-15-19
- Kirsch CPA Group
IRS Announces Changes for Personal Use of Employer-Provided Vehicles
- 06-10-19
- Diane Glover
Watch Out for these Tax Issues When Planning for Your Business in 2018
- 06-26-18
- Diane Glover
What Image Does Your Organization Present to Large Contributors?
- 03-15-18
- Kirsch CPA Group
8 strategies to help you adapt to economic down turn without layoffs
- 02-24-18
- Diane Glover
Remember To Take Required Minimum Distributions at Age 70 1/2 Or Face Penalties
- 02-17-17
- Sue Schloemer
Time is Money: Don’t Spend Valuable Time Inputting Data into QuickBooks
- 06-18-22
- Diane Glover