Tax Benefit of Separating Repairs from Improvements
Kirsch CPA Group
Oct 19, 2020

There’s a world of tax difference between repairs to real estate property and capital improvements. And it’s not just semantics. The characterization could result in an increase or decrease of thousands of dollars on your tax return.
Basic premise
Repairs are currently deductible in full and can be used to offset the tax from rental income. On the other hand, improvements must be written off over a period of years. It takes 27.5 years to write off improvements for residential rental real estate; 39 years for non-residential property. Usually, you’ll prefer to characterize work as repairs in order to benefit from faster write-offs. But you can’t simply call the work a “repair” for your own tax convenience. Instead, you must follow the tax law definitions. Repairs generally do not materially add to the value of the property or prolong its useful life. They merely keep the property in operating condition. Conversely, improvements extend the useful life of the property, increase its value or adapt it for a different use. As an example, fixing a broken window pane is clearly a repair, but installing a new roof is generally treated as an improvement. Note: Repairs may not be currently deductible if the work is included in a “general plan of rehabilitation.” Courts have held that expenses incurred as part of a general plan of rehabilitation must be capitalized even if they otherwise would have been deductible as ordinary and necessary business expenses.
One Case Example
A taxpayer claimed deductions or repairs on his 33 rental real estate properties. He asserted that, beginning five years before, he had planned to capitalize all repair expenses more than $5,000 and to increase that threshold 5% each year. The IRS maintained that 78 percent of the amount claimed for these repairs could be immediately deductible, but the remaining 22% should be capitalized. The taxpayer agreed with the IRS that $30,107 of the claimed $134,863 repair expenses — the 22% established by the IRS — constituted capital expenditures. But then the taxpayer argued before the U.S. Tax Court that he should be allowed to deduct these remaining expenses to make up for the amounts he was not permitted to deduct in earlier years. The taxpayer did not substantiate this claim with any evidence and it was unclear how events transpiring earlier affect the year in issue. Result: He wasn’t entitled to deduct 22% of the repair expenses initially claimed. (Donald Wm. Trask, TC Memo 2010-78).
Another Relevant Tax Court Case
After a tenant complained about a leaky roof on a residential rental house in Long Beach, Calif., the landlord paid $8,000 to have the roof removed and resurfaced and deducted the cost. (No structural changes were made.) The IRS argued it was a capital improvement. According to court documents, “moisture began seeping through the walls into the main bedroom of the house” and the landlord stated that unless the roof was repaired, the house could not continue to be rented. The Tax Court noted that the landlord’s only purpose in having the work done was to prevent leakage and keep the rental property in operating condition “not to prolong the life of the property, increase its value or make it adaptable to another use.” Therefore, the Tax Court determined that the cost was a currently deductible repair and not an improvement. (Campbell, TC Sum Op. 2002-117).
Practical Advice
It is recommended that you separate repair work from capital improvements on invoices if a current deduction is desired. If possible, you might space out the work overtime. For instance, you could have the necessary repairs completed first and then wait several weeks or months to begin improvements. Contact Kirsch CPA Group at 513.858.6040 to provide guidelines for arranging the work.

About The Author
Kirsch CPA Group is a full service CPA and business advisory firm helping businesses and organizations with accounting,…
Tags
Sign Up for Email Updates
Related Articles












Does your Business Deduct Research & Development Expenses? Major Changes Impact 2022 Taxes…
- 11-09-22
- Elizabeth Michalak






Why Have Your Financial Statements Reviewed (Even When Not Required)
- 10-17-22
- Kirsch CPA Group















Case Study: Strategic Accounting Support from Acquisition to Sale
- 09-20-22
- Kirsch CPA Group



























Prevent a Poorly Structured Chart of Accounts from Hiding Your Profitability
- 01-06-22
- Nick Roell















Entrepreneurial Mindset: Kirsch CPA Group Sets a Framework for Growth
- 10-28-21
- Kirsch CPA Group






























What Your Numbers Are Saying: Are You Listening?
Part 2: How Attractive Is Your Balance Sheet?
- 07-19-21
- Kirsch CPA Group












What Your Numbers Are Saying: Are You Listening?
Part 1: Do You Know Your Profitability?
- 06-09-21
- Kirsch CPA Group




































Using Cash Flow Forecasting to Avoid Problems & Grow Your Business
- 04-07-21
- Kirsch CPA Group









Selecting the Right Payroll System for Your Construction Business
- 04-01-21
- Kirsch CPA Group















Self-Employed May Be Eligible for COVID-Related Tax Breaks for 2020
- 03-17-21
- Kirsch CPA Group






COVID-19 Relief: Overview of the New American Rescue Plan Act for Individuals
- 03-17-21
- Kirsch CPA Group



COVID-19 Relief: Business Overview of the New American Rescue Plan Act
- 03-17-21
- Kirsch CPA Group



























Opportunity Zone Investments: A Tax Deferral Opportunity You May Have Overlooked
- 02-17-21
- Kirsch CPA Group




































The Status of Temporary COVID Tax Relief Measures After the New Law
- 01-21-21
- Kirsch CPA Group















8 Accounting Practices for a Financially Healthy Construction Business
- 01-07-21
- Kirsch CPA Group









Appropriations Law Adds Some Business Tax Breaks and Extends Others
- 01-07-21
- Kirsch CPA Group



























Contending With the Patchwork of State Requirements for Nonprofits
- 12-17-20
- Kirsch CPA Group




































Employee or Independent Contractor? The Rules May Be Getting Simpler
- 11-12-20
- Kirsch CPA Group









Do the COVID-19 Extended Deadlines for Health Plans Still Apply?
- 11-12-20
- Kirsch CPA Group












Using Remote Workers? Protect Sensitive Company Data from Exposure
- 10-28-20
- Kirsch CPA Group










































What You Need to Know About the Deferral of Payroll Tax Obligations
- 09-15-20
- Kirsch CPA Group









Hobby or Business? How to Treat COVID-19 Sideline Activities for Taxes
- 09-15-20
- Kirsch CPA Group















Monitor These 3 Things as COVID-19 Changes Your Nonprofit’s Priorities
- 08-11-20
- Kirsch CPA Group












FASB Offers Reprieve from Updated Lease and Revenue Recognition Rules
- 07-23-20
- Kirsch CPA Group






COVID-19 Crisis May Affect Tax Angles for Rental Property Losses
- 07-10-20
- Kirsch CPA Group









Last-Minute Strategies for Businesses that Deferred Filing Tax Returns
- 07-01-20
- Kirsch CPA Group









Can Your Business Survive and Even Thrive in These Trying Times?
- 06-18-20
- Kirsch CPA Group






Five COVID-19 Obstacles a Construction Company Needs to Navigate
- 06-12-20
- Kirsch CPA Group












Cash Flow Tip: Postpone Payment of Certain Federal Employer Payroll Taxes
- 04-20-20
- Sue Schloemer


















Tax Filing Deadline Remains April 15 – Payment Due Extended to July 15
- 03-19-20
- John Kirsch










































8 strategies to help you adapt to economic down turn without layoffs
- 02-24-18
- Diane Glover





















Which Research Activities Qualify for the Qualified Small Business Tax Credits
- 07-17-17
- Diane Glover





































